Sanhedrin bans all Messianic Jewish marriages in Israel

In past posts here at Talk Wisdom, I have shared information regarding how many Jews are seeking out the Messiah, and ultimately becoming Messianic Jews who are believers in Yeshua (Jesus Christ).  Please see:

The Lord Is Gathering His People

So What’s the Difference Between the Christian and the Jew?

Read about a disturbing development in Israel today over at

Sanhedrin bans all Messianic Jewish marriages in Israel.


A rabbinic court, or Sanhedrin, has ruled that a Jew who believes in Jesus as the Jewish Messiah is no longer considered a Jew for purposes of marriage in Israel. This makes it impossible for two Messianic Jews to get married inside the country.

“An Israeli couple who are Messianic Jews cannot marry in a traditional Jewish religious ceremony in Israel because they are considered converts to Christianity, a rabbinical court ruled on Tuesday,” according to the Israeli newspaper Haaretz.

It was the first time a rabbinical court has ruled on the issue of the status of Jews who believe in Jesus as Son of God, after a Messianic couple requested they be married in Israel according to Jewish law or “halacha.”

The couple was essentially told they would need to deny their faith in Jesus as the Son of God to have a state-recognized Jewish wedding ceremony in Israel.

All marriages in Israel are controlled by religious authorities, whether Jewish, Islamic, Christian or Druze, according to laws first handed down under the Ottoman Empire. These laws were retained by the British Mandate and continued after the state of Israel was founded in 1948.

The judges wrote that if the couple “declares before the court they have completely given up their Christian beliefs, including their belonging to a Messianic Jewish community and missionary activities, the court will discuss their matter anew.

[Although] I was disappointed to see the decision of the rabbinic court, it doesn’t surprise me at all,” said Dr. Michael Brown, a Messianic Jewish scholar and author of many books on Christianity and Judaism, including “The Real Kosher Jesus.”

In the eyes of most Orthodox Jews, Messianic Jews are heretics and idolators, unworthy of being part of the larger Jewish community, even though they would consider us still Jews.” Brown told WND. “Many of them want to keep us out of Israel entirely, so refusing to grant two Messianic Jews an official rabbinic wedding is in keeping with their hostility toward us.”

Still, the decision is disappointing, he said, since all official Jewish weddings performed in Israel must be done by Orthodox rabbis, who would gladly perform a ceremony for two atheists.”

Now, I must pause here…”would gladly perform a ceremony for two atheists???” That’s quite shocking! 

So…in the minds of these Orthodox rabbis, it’s better to believe in no God at all (and, therefore, perform marriages for atheists) rather then decline marriage ceremonies for Jews who have come to believe that Jesus Christ is the Jewish Messiah prophesied in Scripture?

Mr. Brown continues:

“So we should protest this decision to the government while still recognizing that our calling to follow Yeshua will bring us persecution and rejection.”

I hope visitors will go to the site and read it all.

Another excerpt:

Messianic Rabbi Zev Porat is founder of the Tel Aviv-based Messiah of Israel Ministries.  He grew up an Orthodox Jew, and his grandfather, Rabbi Pinchas Porat, was a Holocaust survivor who later became one of the heads of the Sanhedrin in Israel.

Porat told WND:

This decision will deprive people of retirement, medical and other benefits that come with a state-recognized marriage.  He said Israel’s Ultra-Orthodox Jewish leaders are celebrating this move because they have long been “furious” about Jews coming to Jesus Christ.”

Porat said in an email to WND it is very important for Jewish believers in Messiah to keep their Jewish identity.



Tags: ,

12 Responses to “Sanhedrin bans all Messianic Jewish marriages in Israel”

  1. GMpilot Says:

    …So you’re surprised that there are bigots in Israel? Where have you been hiding?


  2. Tom Taylor Says:

    Taking into consideration the fact that the Sanhedrin arrested Jesus and put him on trial, this comes as no surprise.


    • christinewjc Says:

      Hi Tom, welcome to my blog. Apologies for this delayed response but I was unable to get online for several days.

      If you visit here again, you will notice that commenter “Robert Pickle” claims that the WND article is full of errors. When I went to the Haaretz site (generally, a reliable source for truth in journalism) the entire article is not available for viewing unless you pay a fee and join the online site.

      I need to take some time to investigate this situation.

      WND is generally a reliable conservative site, and I agree that they are usually a pro-Israel media outlet. If what was written in their article was true and can be backed up by Haaretz and reliable information about the court proceedings and decision on the subject of “Messianic Jews not being allowed to be married in a traditional Jewish ceremony anymore,” then that is (IMHO) a disturbing new development. When I get more information, I will return and comment further.


  3. christinewjc Says:

    Hello Robert Pickle. Welcome to my blog. I looked at the two links you have provided but need to do more research on this topic.

    As you will see in my comment to Tom Taylor, I went to the Haaretz site to compare their report vs. WND, but they require a small fee and online sign-up to view their content.

    I was disgusted with some of the comments that appeared under the WND article, but isn’t that the way it should be because of our USA freedom of speech guaranteed in Article 1 of the U. S. Constitution?

    These days, all kinds of speech are being squelched (or, attempted to be censored) by the media. The violent uprisings of protest by militant leftists (e.g. Antifa) presents more proof of censorship against those with whom they disagree. One example is those Christian business owners who politely turn down participating in homosexual “marriages” and who disagree with any participation in same-sex “marriages” are being sued out of business! Our Supreme Court is taking on that very issue and it will be a very important decision concerning Christians being able to live their lives according to their faith and work their businesses as they see fit according to their belief that marriage is the union of a man and a woman.

    Thank you for stopping by and commenting about your concerns regarding the WND article. Hopefully, the truth about the accuracy of the topic will come out.


    • GMpilot Says:

      So you are surprised that there are anti-Christian bigots in Israel!
      Perhaps I should remind you that Israel has no formal Constitution by which they must abide. Since most Jews do not regard Jesus as their awaited messiah, naturally the more extreme elements would seek to remove even those traces and those believers. Just like the Catholics used to do. Just like the Taliban does now.

      As for WMD, we’ve discussed its alleged accuracy over the years: it’s spotty at best, and borderline libelous at worst. The very fact that someone other than me has brought this article’s lack of accuracy to your attention speaks volumes of that publication’s trustworthiness.

      You’re going to let a small fee and online sign-up stifle your quest for truth? Especially when you’ve admitted that you ‘need to do more research on this topic’? Maybe you should have done the research before you posted–like when you claimed that Obama supporters prevented military votes from being counted back in ’12–before you realized you’d been punked by a humor website.


    • christinewjc Says:

      If it concerns you so much, why don’t you pay the fee, read the article, then cut and paste it in comments for all to read and discuss?


  4. christinewjc Says:

    There are additional links of discussion about the Sanhedrin Initiative at the link provided by Robert Pickle. See The The Sanhedrin Initiative.

    There is no direct reference to the controversy introduced by The Haaretz and WND articles, however we can see that the new efforts to bring about the Sanhedrin Court is discussed here:

    The current attempt to re-establish the Sanhedrin is generally referred to as the “nascent Sanhedrin”, or the “developing Sanhedrin”. This is because the prevailing opinion of the senior members of the Sanhedrin is that the Sanhedrin has not yet achieved halachic [Jewish legal] status on par with its previous position. It does however have the full authority of a Rabbinical court, and is working diligently and with much discussion to satisfy all halachic requirements for complete restoration as soon as possible. There is an enormous amount of work left to be done, so they humbly and urgently request scholars to assist and participate as much as possible to help in overcoming these difficulties. This is a unique opportunity that should not be wasted.

    The spokesman said, “The rebirth of the Sanhedrin is a slow, ongoing process. Although it makes headlines and many like to highlight its controversy, it is in truth a humble project by rabbis from all sides of the Torah world joining together simply to fulfill a Torah commandment. Rather than a source of religious division, G-d forbid, it is a vehicle to bring about Jewish unity and civil justice, to help repair some of the deepest rifts in our society, and to provide an active, exemplary and unified Torah leadership so lacking in our times.”

    I did not see a date on the posting, so it is not clear when it was written.

    I can certainly understand that Messianic Jews would be left out of the “Jewish unity” equation, simply because many religious Jews (particularly the Conservative, Orthodox, and Ultra Orthodox Jews) would view them as Jews who left Judaism for Christianity. However, the Messianic Jews see themselves as authentic Jews too! Why? Because of their heritage, upbringing, location in Israel etc. They desire to have a traditional Jewish wedding, and to be denied one is quite sad (IMHO). It demonstrates a certain kind of hostility towards them simply because they see the Messiah who was prophesied in Scripture as already being fulfilled by Yeshua (Jesus Christ).

    I’m no Jewish scholar, but the fact that the Torah only contains the 5 books of Moses and does not include the writings of the prophets included in the Old Testament Bible, reveals that many Jews do not have the entire historical information needed to understand who Jesus was, is, and forever shall be, because they have not seen or read of the hundreds of prophesies written about (and most already fulfilled) by Him – the true Messiah, Jesus Christ.


  5. christinewjc Says:

    In another link, I found this article:

    The Sanhedrin: Informal translation from Hebrew of the 14 Tishrei, 5770 (2 October 2009) statement.


    Dozens of rabbis from all orthodox branches express their vigorous objection to the takeover by Christian elements of public areas, especially in Jerusalem during the festival of Succot (Tabernacles), when the purpose is missionary propaganda in order to convert Jews.

    Already many years the Succot festival has served as a focal point attracting Christian evangelical groups to perform pilgrimage to Jerusalem. During the intermediary days of the Succot festival, there will be a yearly convention under the auspices of the Christian Embassy in Jerusalem, with the participation of missionary organizations. Among them is “King of Kings”, which is in the Klal building in Jerusalem, Jews for Jesus, and messianic communities, Maoz, Dugit Mishkan, and others. Participants are pilgrams. In the march in Jerusalem, missionaries will also participate. The purpose of them all is to demonstrate the power and Jewish resonance for the purpose of their presence – coronation of Jesus on Jerusalem, as the lion they hold in their hand represents to Christians.

    A substantial portion of the processions and fancy assemblies at Binyanei haUma are used in order to strengthen the missionary propaganda and to strengthen the Christian theology for its divisions which see the Succot festival mainly as a chance to strengthen the Christian influence on the Jewish public while infiltrating Jewish practice: The appropriation of the festivals of Israel, holy Jewish values, while emphasizing their Messiah, seduction of Jewish families with economic and political support, creation of a friendly environment whose entire purpose is to nullify the Jewish identity and to turn it in to a state of all its religions, that is to say, Christian.

    These activities are conversion attempts, which have taken form in recent years as a Judeo-Christian religion with Jews for Jesus, or God’s Witnesses, messianic communities (believing in their messiah), Christian sects in every way which have founded some hundred fifty branches throughout the country, and it is estimated that some 20,000 have left their religion.

    Per the decisions of the Rabbinate of Israel, the organizations of evangelical Christian sects and the messianic communities to which they are partners are all apostates in every way, and undercut the faith of Israel and corrupt the national identity. It is forbidden to participate in their gatherings and to march with them.

    Today in a context where states, nations, and religions attempt to undercut the legitimacy of the State of Israel as a Jewish state, it is proper to doubly stand for the uniqueness of the State of Israel and the national uniqueness of the nation of Israel and the religion of Israel, and to develop the unique Jewish identity and to remain faithful Jews to our forefathers tradition.

    Freedom of religion in Israel does not mean freedom to make propaganda to convert to other religions.


  6. christinewjc Says:

    Another link includes criticism of Pope Benedict’s 2009 visit to Israel.

    The The Disgrace of the Pope’s visit to the Temple Mount on Lag Ba’Omer


    The authorities of the state have cultivated without proportion and without honor the visit of the head of the religion that has caused trouble for the nation of Israel, amidst motives of cheap flattery and trampling of the national and religious honor. Forgotten is the desire of this idolatrous religion for the erasing and degradation of the nation of G-d.

    The current Pope was head of the Christian Inquisition, known as the “Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith”. He holds the role of Pope with pride and without deviation as Pontiff of Rome as the burnt tongues of fire of the Inquisitors and the “Knights” of blood of the Crusades are licking at the edges of Jerusalem.

    As a former Catholic turned born-again Christian (over 30 years ago) I recognize the important differences between Roman Catholicism and Biblical Christianity. I put in a search for “The Christian Inquisition and Pope Benedict.” Many alarming links to read! One link does say that he apologized for the sins of the past in Roman Catholicism. Some links mentioned the Catholic priest sexual abuse scandals.

    It is understandable that the Sanhedrin would not have trusted (or wanted) Benedict’s visit to the Temple Mount in Israel I just hope and pray that they would know (or, one day recognize) the huge differences between Roman Catholicism and Biblical Christianity.


  7. GMpilot Says:

    CJW: If it concerns you so much, why don’t you pay the fee, read the article, then cut and paste it in comments for all to read and discuss?

    Because I’m not the one raising the alarm about it and posting it on a blog. I’m neither Christian nor Jewish–I don’t have a horse in this race. What ‘concerns’ me, if anything, is your Chicken Little approach to the story.

    I put in a search for “The Christian Inquisition and Pope Benedict.” Many alarming links to read! One link does say that he apologized for the sins of the past in Roman Catholicism.

    I seem to recall that Benedict never apologized for what the Church did; it was all done by people who were ‘acting in the name of the Church’. The difference is subtle, but definite. But just what is a church, if not the people who comprise it?

    Whatever happened to the boast “Talk Wisdom reports, you decide”? If you’re doing the reporting (or in this case, reposting), it’s your responsibility to be as accurate as possible–which, according to both Mr. Pickle and yourself, you have not been.


  8. christinewjc Says:

    I’m having trouble with my computer today. Many of the links continue to “buffer” or I get the message that the website is “not responding.”

    Anyway, at least I got a copy of the link at the Jerusalem Post that picked up the story written about in this post.

    Jerusalem Post: Senior national religious Rabbis declare opposition to civil marriage.

    There is also an updated article at WND:

    WND: Sanhedrin accused of trying to delegitimize Jews who believe in Christ.


  9. GMpilot Says:

    I knew it wouldn’t be difficult for someone as web-savvy as you to find some other way! Bravo Zulu!

    The Jerusalem Post article is most interesting. If I read it correctly, it means that if you converted to anything other than Orthodox Judaism, you would not be allowed to marry, never mind what Yahweh says.

    [Rabbi Yuval] Cherlow says that he is extremely reticent to permit full civil marriage, saying that it would give a terrible message to the rest of world Jewry that the biggest Jewish community in the world, Israel, would in effect make inter-faith marriage between Jews and non-Jews legitimate.
    “It would be tantamount to Israel saying that it has given up on the fight against assimilation and intermarriage, and we mustn’t give that message,” said Cherlow.

    Hmmm. So we condemn Germany for doing a very similar thing eighty years ago, but condone Israel for doing it now? Maybe I’ve missed something here.

    WND quotes the Messianic rabbi Zev Porat:

    “For years Jews have been getting married with the sole question ‘are you a Jew,’ and you say ‘yes.’ But now they are not satisfied with that answer. They want to know if you are a Jew who believes in Jesus,” Porat continued.
    “They are Jews but have never been asked if they are also a believer in Jesus, until now. If you say yes, they will say ‘you’re not a Jew in our category, and, if you are not a Jew, you are not getting married.’”
    Jews who may be atheist or Buddhist, by contrast, are not asked to prove their Jewishness by answering any religiously based questions, Porat told WND.

    We know there has long been an upsurge of religious fundamentalism in the world. There’s no reason whatever to think that Israel is immune to such things; after all, Jews have been told before not to intermarry with believers in other faiths, and even to kill them. But since genocide is mostly frowned upon these days, socially disenfranchising them is the way to go.

    Apparently the regathered Sanhedrin are out to Make Israel Great Again…and only True Jews are to be allowed.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: